Pin it
Earthy mushrooms meet aromatic garlic in this wonderfully balanced pasta dish. The richness comes from a velvety, buttery sauce, while fresh lemon adds brightness and Parmesan brings a deep umami kick that'll make you crave every single forkful.
I've thrown this together so many times—from rushed Tuesday night meals to dinner gatherings with friends. It's one of those rare gems that's super easy but looks like you put in tons of effort. Just don't rush those mushrooms when they're browning. That golden color is worth waiting for, trust me.
Key Components and Shopping Advice
- Cremini Mushrooms: Go for ones that feel firm with unbroken caps and no moisture. Stay away from mushrooms that feel wet or show darker patches.
- Pappardelle: The broad, flat shape of these noodles really grabs onto the sauce. Try to find ones made with eggs for added richness.
- Parmesan Cheese: Skip the container stuff and get a chunk to grate yourself—it'll melt into your sauce way better.
- Fresh Parsley: Pick bunches that look vibrant green and perky. Don't toss the stems—they pack extra flavor.
- Dijon Mustard: Grab the real French stuff for that zingy flavor that makes mushrooms taste even better.
Step-by-Step Cooking Guide
- Step 1: Getting Your Pasta Just Right
- Make your water as salty as ocean water. Once you drop in the pasta, give it a good stir right away so it doesn't clump. Keep testing until it's al dente—still a bit firm when you bite it. Don't forget to save some water before draining—you'll need it for your sauce.
- Step 2: Cooking Mushrooms to Perfection
- Give those mushrooms plenty of space in the pan. They need room to brown properly. Don't keep moving them around too much. You'll see them release water first, then wait for that moisture to cook off. They're ready when you see those nice golden edges.
- Step 3: Putting Together Your Amazing Sauce
- Cook the garlic just until you can smell it—too long and it gets bitter. Add your Dijon bit by bit while stirring. Let everything bubble just enough to thicken slightly. Splash in pasta water as needed while mixing to get the sauce exactly how you want it.
Pin it
Coming from an Italian family, I learned early on that when it comes to simple pasta dishes, ingredients matter so much. My mom always told me that fewer ingredients means each one needs to be top quality. Fresh mushrooms are absolutely crucial here—they're the real star of this dish.
What gets me every time is how uncomplicated this dish is. I'm always blown away by how just a handful of everyday ingredients can turn into something that tastes so fancy.
Pin it
This dish has turned into my favorite pick-me-up meal. I make it when I'm alone or when friends come over, and it always gets compliments for its simple elegance and deeply satisfying flavors.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which mushrooms should I pick?
- Cremini are top-notch, though portobello or white buttons are good too.
- → Can I switch pasta shapes?
- Yep, any medium pasta works great like bowties, rotini, or penne.
- → Why include Dijon mustard?
- It gives the sauce a pleasant tangy depth, amping up the dish!
- → Can this be stored or made ahead?
- Serve immediately since the pasta absorbs the sauce over time.
- → How to make it more rich?
- Light cream with the broth can turn it into a creamier sauce.