Pin it
Since grabbing my Ninja Creami, I've totally fallen for crafting ice cream at home. This cool gadget has changed my whole outlook on frozen treats. I'm now constantly mixing up protein-rich snacks or luxurious dairy-free options - it's become my go-to kitchen buddy for whipping up amazing frozen desserts myself.
Why You'll Love This Tasty Creation
What I adore is how basic yet adaptable this foundation recipe can be. Using just a handful of items, I'm able to create upwards of 52 different taste combinations for any sweet tooth moment. I really like the smaller portions for watching what I eat and trying out fresh ideas. They turn out so silky and rich that they beat what I'd buy at my neighborhood scoop shop.
Key Components
- Cream cheese: Here's our magic ingredient for that velvety feel - pick whatever type matches your eating plan.
- Heavy cream: Stick with standard heavy cream instead of the whipping kind to get the best texture.
- Milk: I prefer whole milk but honestly any milk does the job, including plant-based alternatives.
- Sugar: Plain white sugar works perfectly, or switch to allulose if you want a sugar-free option.
- Vanilla extract: Real vanilla upgrades everything, and vanilla bean paste works wonderfully too.
Easy-to-Follow Process
- Step 1 - Get Your Mix Ready for Freezing
- Begin by softly warming your cream cheese with some cream, then mix in the sugar until it's completely gone. Dump everything in your pint container, add what's left of your ingredients, stir it well, then stick it in the freezer for 3+ hours.
- Step 2 - Process Your Mixture
- After freezing, lock your container into the machine, pick ice cream or lite ice cream mode and let it do its thing. Don't worry if it seems a bit chunky - just run it through again.
- Step 3 - Enjoy Your Creation
- Dish up your smooth creation into bowls or cones. Want to toss in extras like chocolate chips? Wait until it's nearly smooth first.
Insider Tricks
Make sure you don't overfill your container - always keep that half inch gap at the top. Go with the ice cream or lite ice cream programs for the smoothest results. Three hours freezing works fine but leaving it overnight is way better. Always feel free to run your mix through the machine several times to get just the right smoothness.
Tasty Variations to Sample
Some top picks I make include traditional cookies and cream with smashed Oreos, muscle-building chocolate using protein drinks and pudding mix, and banana cream pie with fresh bananas. If you're into fruits, give mixed berry or mango sorbet a shot. And everyone always goes crazy for mint chocolate chip with those small morsels.
Storage Tips
Just tuck any extra ice cream back in the freezer right in the same pint container. When you want more, run it through the machine again. It stays good about a week, but truthfully, it's always gone much faster at my place.
Pin it
Answers to Your Questions
The churning typically needs about 3-4 minutes, and if you want it harder, just pop it back in the freezer for another 30 minutes. Don't worry about those icy bits on top, they'll vanish when you churn it. And yep, you can make one batch after another without waiting - the machine handles it like a champ.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How long does this stay good?
- Tastes best in 2 days. If it's too firm, let it soften at room temp for 10–15 minutes.
- → Why do a second spin?
- Double spinning makes it smoother when it's crumbly after the first spin.
- → Can mix-ins be used?
- Absolutely! Add them post-churn and use the mix-in mode to combine.
- → Why soften the cream cheese first?
- Softened cream cheese blends easily without leaving clumps behind.
- → Can non-dairy milk be used?
- Sure, but the texture might be a little different. Regular milk works best.