Pin it
This velvety peanut butter pie doesn't need any baking, making it popular all year round. The smooth, creamy filling paired with the crispy Oreo base gives you a mouthwatering texture combo that takes me back to those addictive peanut butter cups, but in a more sophisticated form.
When I first whipped this up for my daughter's party, it was gone in minutes, so I started doubling the recipe. These days it's our family's top dessert request, particularly at summer cookouts when nobody wants to heat up the kitchen.
Key Components
- Oreos: Stick with original ones, not double-stuffed - they break down into the best crust texture
- Cream Cheese: Use the full-fat kind at room temp for the creamiest results
- Peanut Butter: Commercial types like Skippy or Jif work better than natural ones
- Heavy Cream: Keep it super cold until you're ready to whip it
- Powdered Sugar: Blends in smoothly without any gritty feel
- Vanilla Extract: Enhances the peanut butter's richness
Pin it
Step-by-Step Guide
- Step 1:
- Leave your cream cheese out for at least 2 hours - you'll get lumps if it's not totally soft.
- Step 2:
- When breaking down the Oreos, don't overdo it - aim for fine crumbs but not dust.
- Step 3:
- Add butter to your crumbs bit by bit until the mix feels similar to damp sand.
- Step 4:
- Pack down your crust with a measuring cup's bottom, focusing on where the sides meet the base.
- Step 5:
- Let the crust get properly cold and firm - this keeps it from breaking when you add your filling.
- Step 6:
- Beat cream in a cool bowl to soft peaks, then mix in sugar and continue until stiff.
- Step 7:
- Make sure to whip the cream cheese by itself first until it's completely lump-free.
- Step 8:
- Mix peanut butter into the cream cheese slowly, scraping the sides frequently.
- Step 9:
- Carefully blend in the whipped cream with gentle motions to keep it fluffy.
- Step 10:
- Let it chill thoroughly for easy, clean cutting.
We found out that slightly frozen pieces are fantastic during hot weather. My grandson calls it his "peanut butter ice cream pie" and it's always his birthday dessert of choice.
Impressive Party Dessert
Making this pie in advance takes the pressure off when you're hosting. The filling stays firm for hours, and the base keeps its satisfying crunch.
Tasty Year-Round Options
In summer, try the frozen version with chocolate sauce drizzled on top, while fall and winter gatherings might feature hot butterscotch and sprinkled nuts.
Pin it
Prep-Ahead Wonder
This dessert actually gets better after spending a day in the fridge as the flavors blend together and the texture becomes just right.
This no-bake peanut butter pie has turned into my trademark dessert that everyone expects me to bring along. It's so easy and foolproof that it works for any event, and its rich, dreamy texture means empty dishes and happy faces every single time.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Is it possible to prepare this pie in advance?
- You can prep it up to 3 days early in the fridge or store in the freezer for a month.
- → Why should the cream cheese not be cold?
- When it's softened, it blends better for a lump-free filling.
- → Could I use chunky peanut butter instead?
- It's best to stick with the creamy kind to keep the filling extra smooth.
- → No chocolate graham crackers available, what now?
- Try Oreo cookies or chocolate Teddy Grahams instead. Both taste great!
- → Can this pie work without peanut butter?
- Swap it with almond butter. Check the adjusted steps in the notes.