Pin it
Say goodbye to your old tuna salad with this protein-loaded twist that uses cottage cheese instead of mayo. You'll get amazing tangy, smooth, and crunchy bites with a hefty 29 grams of protein in each serving. The fresh herbs mixed with zingy lemon and crisp veggies make this meal both super healthy and incredibly tasty.
I threw this together during a hectic meal prep day and couldn't believe how flexible it was. My teenage son, who usually turns his nose up at anything "healthy," grabbed another helping and wanted it in his lunch the next day. The trick? Smoothing out the cottage cheese completely - it makes the perfect creamy base with none of that cottage cheese lumpiness.
Key Ingredients and Shopping Advice
- Cottage cheese: Grab small curd, full-fat for the smoothest result when blended
- Canned tuna: Go for solid white albacore for better chunks and milder taste
- Red onion: Pick ones that feel heavy and soak your chopped bits in cold water to cut the bite
- Celery: Look for bright green, snappy stalks for extra crunch
- Dill pickles: Buy whole, crisp ones and chop them yourself for better flavor
- Fresh garlic: Make sure cloves feel firm and grate them just before mixing
- Fresh lemon: Choose ones that feel weighty with smooth, bright peels
- Fresh herbs: Get bright, perky bunches for the most flavor punch
Step-by-Step Mixing Guide
- Step 1:
- Get Your Base Ready: Pour off any extra liquid from cottage cheese. Blend until silky smooth with a stick blender. Keep some on the side to fix thickness later. Add salt and pepper as you like. Wait 5 minutes for flavors to sink in.
- Step 2:
- Prep Your Tuna: Squeeze out all liquid completely. Break it up into tiny, even bits with a fork. Look for any stray bones. Leave some bigger pieces for texture.
- Step 3:
- Mix Everything Together: Start with tuna and smooth cottage cheese. Slowly add your chopped veggies. Gently fold in your herbs and spices. Adjust how wet or dry it is. Let it sit so flavors can blend.
Pin it
Just last week I brought this tuna mix to our family outing. The cottage cheese version stayed perfectly tasty even after sitting in a cooler for hours. Nobody could tell it wasn't made with mayo - they were all fooled by how creamy and rich it tasted.
Prep Ahead Tricks
Keep everything fresh by cutting veggies and storing them separately from your tuna mix. This stops them from going soft and keeps their crunch intact. When you're ready to eat, just throw everything together and check if it needs more seasoning.
Ways to Enjoy It
This flexible salad works for tons of different meals throughout your week. Stuff it in whole grain pitas, wrap it in lettuce leaves, or pile it on cucumber slices if you're watching carbs. For a protein-packed snack, scoop it up with whole grain crackers or fresh cut veggies.
Fun Twists to Try
The standard recipe can be changed up in so many ways. Mix in diced apple for sweetness, add curry powder for warmth, or toss in capers for tangy zip. Want even more protein? Mix in chopped eggs. Each change gives you a whole new meal while keeping all that good protein.
Pin it
This protein-packed tuna mix has become my favorite lunch. It shows that healthier options can taste just as good as the classics - sometimes even better! Whether you're counting protein, avoiding mayo, or just need quick meal ideas, this recipe checks all the boxes.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What’s better about cottage cheese here?
- It keeps things creamy and adds protein, making it healthier than regular mayo.
- → Can I skip blending the cheese?
- Sure thing! Leave it chunky if that’s your style.
- → How long can I keep it fresh?
- Seal it tight and pop it in the fridge—it's good for 3-4 days.
- → What kind of tuna is best?
- Go for white albacore—it’s firm and has a mild, clean flavor.
- → Can I add my favorite veggies?
- Absolutely! Toss in cucumber, peppers, or anything crunchy.