Pin it
Turn boring veggies into an amazing sandwich experience by stacking tangy pickled onions, smooth spreads, and crisp produce. This creation brings out the natural goodness of each ingredient, giving you the perfect mix of textures and flavors in every mouthful.
I came up with this combo while trying to copy a sandwich from my go-to café. After lots of testing, this version beats the original hands down and now we can't go a week without it.
Picking Your Ingredients:
- Sourdough bread: Get the craft kind with tough outer crust and soft, chewy middle
- Cream cheese: Use the regular kind, not light, and let it warm up first
- Greek yogurt: Drain it a bit if it seems too runny
- Fresh herbs: Look for vibrant ones without any brown spots
- Tomatoes: Choose ones that aren't mushy but still feel ripe (heirlooms work best)
- Avocados: They should give just a little when you squeeze them
- English cucumber: The skinny kind with thin peel
- Red onions: Pick tight, firm ones with no softness
- Sprouts: Make sure they're dry and snappy
Follow These Steps:
- Fast Pickle Those Onions:
- Cut red onion into super thin rings about 1/8-inch thick. Toss in a bowl with one lime's juice, 1 teaspoon salt, 1/2 teaspoon pepper. Let them sit for half an hour, giving them a stir every 10 minutes. They'll get softer and turn bright pink.
- Whip Up Herby Cream Cheese:
- Whip softened cream cheese until it's light and fluffy (about 2 minutes). Slowly mix in Greek yogurt until smooth. Add salt, pepper, onion powder, and chopped fresh herbs. Let it hang out for 30 minutes so flavors can mingle.
- Get Your Bread Ready:
- Turn your broiler on high. Spread butter all over one side of each bread slice. Put them butter-side up on a baking sheet. Broil for 2-3 minutes, turning halfway, until they're golden but still soft inside.
- Fix Those Tomatoes:
- Cut tomatoes into slices about 3/8-inch thick. Put them on paper towels, sprinkle both sides with plenty of salt and pepper. Let them drain for 10 minutes per side. Pat them dry before using.
- Mash Your Avocado:
- In a bowl, smash avocados as chunky or smooth as you like. Mix in lemon juice and salt right away to keep them green. For super smooth results, throw it in a food processor.
- Put It All Together:
- Lay bread with toasted sides facing up. Spread herb cream cheese on one slice, avocado mix on the other. Stack tomatoes, cucumber, and those pink onions on the cream cheese side. Add cheese if you want. Top with a big handful of sprouts and spinach. Close it up and press down gently.
Pin it
Every part matters here. The pickled onions bring zing, the two spreads add richness, and the fresh veggies give you that nice crunch.
Prep Ahead Options:
Make those pickled onions up to a week early. Mix up the herb spread 3 days before. Cut your veggies the morning you plan to eat.
Keeping Everything Fresh:
Store everything in different containers. Put plastic wrap right on top of the avocado mix to stop it from turning brown.
What Goes Well With It:
Try it with a light soup when it's cold out or a fresh salad in summer. Chilled cucumber soup tastes great with it any time of year.
Pin it
This sandwich turns ordinary veggies into a real meal. The mix of tangy pickled onions, creamy spreads, and garden-fresh vegetables creates so many flavor layers that even meat-lovers won't miss a thing.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can the herb spread be prepped early?
- You can make it up to five days in advance and keep it refrigerated.
- → Tricks to avoid soggy toast?
- Spread the cream cheese on the toasted side, then layer tomatoes over it.
- → What bread works best if I don’t have sourdough?
- Go for any sturdy, toastable bread.
- → How long will pickled onions keep?
- Refrigerated quick-pickled onions last around a week.
- → Can this toast be made vegan?
- Yes, swap the cream cheese for a dairy-free version and skip the Havarti.